My favorite comfortable tall boots finally bit the dust after ten years. They were a wonderful pair of Naturalizer taupe leather boots with a low heel and cushioned footbed that fit my narrow calves perfectly. Then the bootie-shootie craze took off and I forgot all about knee-high boots.
But I’m happily seeing a comeback and I’m here for it. I love how they support the ankles, provide warmth and lengthen the leg visually. I’ve done the digging for you and discovered 10 comfortable tall boots for varying calf sizes, foot issues and price points. Take a look!
The first one in the round-up of comfortable tall boots is my new adjustable-calf Sofft Sharnells. While I can tuck my jeans into them, the fit is pretty tight. I prefer wearing them with skirts and dresses.
“Love! These are so great! It is tough to find a boot to fit my slim calves.” – Zappos customer Jo
Aren’t these beauties? If your calf circumference is under 15″, the Sofft Sharnell II is a great boot to try. Stain-resistant, waterproof Italian leathers make up the upper and shaft keeping your feet dry while a cushioned footbed and arch provide all-day comfort. Update 12/25: I purchaed a pair of these beauties and love them. Like I’ve mentioned I have narrow calves (don’t be jealous, my disproportionate thighs are a different story). The Sofft Sharnell II keeps my feet dry and supported and fits snug around the calves.
Sofft Sharnell II
• Sizes: 6-11 • Width: M • Calf circumference: 13″ adjusting to 15″: • Price: $186-249 from Sofft, Zappos, Amazon (find a deal on eBay)
2. Aerosoles Binocular Shearling
Sometimes a low wedge feels better on aching feet than a typical flat or block heel and the Aerosoles Binocular is an affordable option! The faux suede upper has a little stretch to it and the shearling trim is just around the top of the boot.
• Sizes: 5-12 • Width: M & W • Calf circumference: 16″ • Price: $89-149 from Aerosoles, Amazon & Zappos
3. Dingo Vagabond
“Super cute. Beautiful leather, great style to wear with dresses, jeans and skirts. Classic and will last for years! I wear 7, ordered a 7 1/2 to allow for orthotics. Slightly narrow but fit great if I wear thinner socks. Very happy!!!” – Nordstrom customer
Are the beautiful Frye Campus boots out of your budget? Mine too. The Dingo Vagabond is high quality dupe for less than half the price of the Fryes. Customer reviews are mostly positive for good fit and feel (keep in mind this is a pull-on style–no zipper).
What sets this lovely tall boot apart is Abeo’s BIOsystem® orthotic footbed, designed to support your arches, cushion your heels, and keep your body aligned. The deep heel cup absorbs shock, while the roomy toe box takes pressure off the bunions. Whether you deal with plantar fasciitis, metatarsalgia, or just tired feet, these comfortable knee-high boots are built to help relieve pain and fatigue while staying stylish.
• Sizes: 5-11 • Width: M • Footbed style: regular support & metatarsal support • Price: $279.95 from Nordstrom, Amazon & The Walking Company
5. Miz Mooz Lisbon: regular and wide calf available
“Oh my goodness, this boot is amazing! Love the soft look and spacious toe box. Perfect for dresses and skirts. Wore it all day right out of the box.” Miz Mooz customer, Carmelita
It’s all in the details. Portuguese-made Miz Mooz Lisbon kicks the regular riding boot up a notch in the Lisbon boot with its slightly slouched design with ruching and supple leather upper in rich hues. A padded footbed and low one-inch heel add to its all-day comfort.
• Sizes: 6-11 • Width: M • Calf Circumference: regular – 15″ & wide – 16″ • Price: $249.95 from Miz Mooz, Nordstrom & Amazon (regular calf only)
6. Clarks Adalynn Hope
Real leather boots are typically priced over $150 but I found a beautiful pair for under $140! The Clarks Adalynn Hope tall boot features a densely padded footbed with extra cushioning at the heel and ball of foot, a round toe and a rubber lug sole for stability.
• Sizes: 5-12 • Width: M & W (this is foot width, not calf width) • Calf circumference: 14 1/8″ • Price: $129-139.99 from Clarks & Amazon
Lifestride Xtrovert
Here’s a waterproof tall boot that comes in both a wide foot option and a wide calf option. It may not be real leather, but the price is unbeatable. Customer reviews are generally positive for comfort and fit.
• Sizes: 5-11 • Foot Width: M & W • Calf Circumference: 14 3/8″ & 16 5/8″ • Price: $55-65.99 from Lifestride & Amazon.
View Comments
Those Sharnells can fit a wide calf, too. I’m at least 17” and you can loosen them up enough. And they’re comfy!