Comfortable Boots for women

Published on January 5th, 2015 | by Kirsten Borrink


Baffin Boots Review – Blissful, Waterproof Winter Warmth

Baffin boots

Baffin Boots Charlee courtesy of

I’m finally trying out my new Baffin boots – who would have thought we’d have to wait until January for snow? It’s here now and more is on the way for Chicagoland tomorrow night..sigh. My old winter boots, a discontinued style by Sorel, became a chew toy for my Wheaten Terrier. Every time I’d put them on, he’d latch on to the leather pull tab with his teeth for a “ride” around the yard. He considered this a good time. My boots did not.

Last winter’s polar vortex caused a permanent scar to this girl’s psyche, leaving me weak-kneed and chickenhearted; afraid to face another winter with sub-z temps. I knew I needed a warm boot. I’ve done the overly furry Ugg boots in the past and find I overheat in grocery stores–it’s embarrassing but proves the thought that if your feet are warm, so is the rest of your body. I came across Baffin boots with their Canada maple leaf logo with the claim, “Polar Proven.” That sounds promising, doesn’t it? Then I looked at the styles and read the reviews–continued good news! Cold-footed people all over the country like these boots for warmth and all-day comfort. I contacted Baffin and asked if they’d consider sending a pair for review.

I’m happy to introduce you to the Charlee style by Baffin. There’s no fur or fluff, but this cute boot knows when to warm my feet up and when to back off.

baffin boots

Here’s what I love about the Baffin Charlee:

  • Roomy fit. The boot comes in whole sizes only, so I went with the 10 for my 9.5-10 medium width foot and I’m glad I did for two reasons: room for thick socks, room for an added insole. The fit is wide through the midfoot, so I snugged up the fit by adding an insole from my gym shoes. Voila!
  • Better support than Ugg Classics. The EVA midsole and rubber outsole provide both cushioning and a sturdy feel with every step. Remember, they’re roomy so you can add your favorite arch support insole.
  • Warm, but not overly so. The Charlee features something called “B-TEK 4-Channel Hollow Fiber Insulation.” This layer traps air, maintaining a constant temperature and providing excellent thermal resistance. Honestly, I can wear these to run errands and my feet are just as comfortable in the frigid car and strolling the sidewalks as they are pushing a cart at Trader Joes. We just got back from a visit to see family in Connecticut. We spent a day in Manhattan where the temps hovered around 34. My feet felt great.
  • They’re waterproof! This was tested during a slush storm a few days ago. I parked in one of those spots with slush puddles right at the driver side door. I considered jumping over it as I often advise my sons, but decided to step right in. I also did the same on the way back. No seeping! The uppers are made of “Timberwolf nubuck” which are treated with silicone to make them waterproof.
  • The style. Simple black with two adjustable buckles–one at the instep and one at the calf.
  • The calf fit. A 16 1/2″ calf circumference allows me to wear leggings, thick knee socks, tucked in jeans.

I would recommend the Baffin Charlee or other similar Baffin boots for women with a wider foot or bunions; or for someone needing room for an orthotic.

The Baffin Charlee is available in whole sizes 6-11, black, brown and gray nubuck at Zappos, and Amazon.

Have you worn any Baffin boots in past winters? Ready for winter 2015? What will you be wearing? Let me know in comments below.






About the Author

Blogger, Wife, Mom, Dog-Lover, Coffee Drinker, Owl Watcher.

7 Responses to Baffin Boots Review – Blissful, Waterproof Winter Warmth

  1. Sarah Bleviss says:

    Thanks for the tip! I also want to give a recommendation of the Cougar Vienna 5 which I found to be extremely cute, great traction, generous sizing (I usually wear a 7.5W but they only have medium so I got an 8M and it fits great), generous calf sizing (I have wide calves and these fit greats with tights or jeans), and are very cute and very very waterproof!

    Best of all? They accommodate my orthodics!

    There are some good sales, too, but here is the link:

  2. Evelyn says:

    Thanks for the sharing your views about Baffin Charlee. This will help in easy decision making.

    Running Trainers Womens

  3. Jody Link says:

    These look great but I am looking for something with a very cushy sole. I have fibromyalgia and plantar facitis and wear orthotics but recently have been having problems with my orthotics too. The only solution so far have been Klogs – Dusty model – I wore them walking all over in D.C. last week without pain!! But they do not make any tall boots. Any ideas for a tall boot with a similar sole? My Bear Paw (UGG type) boots hurt my feet even with orthotics in them!

  4. Emily says:

    Do you feel the sole is ridged enough for someone Ruth hallux rigidus? Mine is progressing and I’m trying to delay surgery as long as possible.

  5. Kirsten says:

    No, I’ve worn these for a year now and while they’re cushioned and roomy, I wouldn’t say the sole is rigid enough to protect a hallux rig. toe. I absolutely love Dansko’s line of rocker sole winter boots. In this post I feature the Candice, Camryn and Chelsea boots by Dansko. The Candice is last year’s model and is on sale now I believe at Amazon: I have a shoe from this collection and it’s wonderful for protecting the forefoot joints. I’d also recommend the Alegria Nanook with its fairly rigid sole. I hope this helps.

  6. Martha Smith says:

    I would really love your suggestions.
    My question is what are your ultimate favorite go to daily shoe and boot for fall weather ranging from 50-35 degrees?

    And second, what are your most favorite or go to winter cold and or snow boot and or snow shoe for 35 degrees and below?

    Essentially which shoes or boots do you wear and reach for the most?
    I live in Dallas Texas and I live in my Birkenstock sandals from February when it is 75 degrees here, until October. I have one pair of Birkenstock Bennington ankle boots that I am going to bust out for October to December. But come December our temperatures drop to 10-20 degrees at the lowest. However, I do have to travel this winter to the bitter cold and snow drenched North.

    Thank you for your help,

  7. Kirsten Borrink says:

    I am soooo minimalist! I too wear Birkenstock Arizonas as long as I can. I even had them on in 50 degree weather today here in Chicago. When the temps dip a little lower, I like to wear my Dansko Celeste slip-ons The support is good and they keep my feet pretty warm. I also still love my Merrell Salida hiking boots–good support, wide toe box, good traction and I believe they have a Gortex version for cold temps. I don’t own (but wish I did) Romika Citytex boots. They’re waterproof, and look dressier than a hiker!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Back to Top ↑
  • Who is behind
    Kirsten Borrink has reviewed over 1,705 comfortable shoes since 2007. Read More...

  • Popular Posts